For every cookie purchased, we donate a meal. 1 cookie = 1 meal. 

This section doesn’t currently include any content. Add content to this section using the sidebar.

Image caption appears here

Add your deal, information or promotional text

The Perfect Fall Cookie Recipe To Enjoy All Year Long

The Perfect Fall Cookie Recipe To Enjoy All Year Long

All The Pumpkin-Flavored Deliciousness That You’ve Been Waiting For All Year Can Last All Year!

Ah, Fall. It’s a beautiful season, loved by many for the colorful leaves, chilly air, and, of course, the pumpkin-flavored treats. There’s nothing like a delicious pumpkin cookie with a hot drink on a brisk Fall day. But what if you’re craving that spice and warmth in the middle of Spring?

Enjoying some sweet seasonal treats anytime of year is the definition of self-care.

Even with Fall having come and gone, you can still get into the kitchen and bake all the delicious pumpkin-flavored treats that your heart desires. As cookie experts ourselves, we at Nunbelievable thought we’d step in and present you with a little gift – a pumpkin cookie recipe that is second to nun! 

Nunbelievable Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookies: The Ingredients You’ll Need

These pumpkin chocolate chip cookies are absolutely saintly. They’ll fill your tummy with joy, and they’re the perfect seasonal treats to share with your family while cuddling up and watching a movie on a chilly night. 

Here are the ingredients you’ll need to bake these sweet Fall treats.

  • 2 Cups of All-Purpose Flour or Gluten-Free Alternative: You can bake these cookies with standard all-purpose flour, whole wheat flour, or a gluten-free flour made from rice, coconut, or almonds – it’s up to you!

  • 1 Cup Dark Chocolate Chips: We love using dark chocolate when we bake because of its complex, slightly bitter taste. However, if you prefer, you can stick with semi-sweet milk chocolate chips for your cookies!

  • 1 Can of Pumpkin Puree: This is the ingredient that gives these cookies their distinct Fall flavor. You’ll need a whole can of pumpkin puree for a batch of 30 cookies, but you can use half a can to make a smaller batch.

  • 2 tsp Cinnamon: To keep things simple, this is the only spice you’ll be using to bake your batch of cookies. If you want, though, you can add a pinch of nutmeg for some extra warm, nutty flavor notes.

  • 1 Egg: Eggs help to keep your dough held together and are a key ingredient in the dough that we use to bake all Nunbelievable cookies. Just one egg is enough for your whole batch of dough.

  • 1 Cup Brown Sugar: Brown sugar is the perfect source of sweetness for these autumnal cookies. It pairs perfectly with cinnamon and pumpkin to create a distinct flavor that you’ll love!

  • 2½ tsp Baking Powder: Baking powder helps your dough rise.

  • ½ Cup Vegetable Oil

  • Once you’ve gathered your ingredients, you’re ready to start prepping!

    Let’s Make Some Dough

    The first step in preparing your cookies is to preheat your oven. That way, it’ll be ready to go by the time you’ve finished making your dough. Preheat the oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit – perfect cookie-baking temperature.

    Next, combine your flour, baking powder, and cinnamon with a pinch of salt in a large bowl. Starting with these dry ingredients gives you the foundation for your dough.

    Once the dry ingredients are mixed, take the bowl from your electric mixer and use the mixer’s paddle or whisk attachment to combine the vegetable oil and brown sugar. This mixture will be combined with the dry ingredients shortly to make your dough. 

    Next, add the egg and pumpkin puree to the mixer and blend them with the sugar and oil. For the final components of your dough, add the mixed dry ingredients from your separate bowl to the mixing bowl. With your electric mixer set on low, blend the dry ingredients with the rest of the mixture to form your dough. 

    To add the finishing touches to your dough, add the chocolate chips to the mixture and gently blend them with the rest of the dough. At this point, you’ve got the foundations for your batch of incredible cookies!

    Prepping Time

    Once you’ve got your dough, it’s time to portion it in even amounts to get the perfect-sized cookies. For a batch of 30 smaller cookies, you can use two tablespoons of dough per cookie. If you want, you can cut the size of your batch in half and get 15 double-sized cookies by using four tablespoons of dough per batch – it’s up to you!

    Portion your dough out on sheets of parchment paper. To keep your cookies from baking into each other, space them out by a few inches (remember, they’ll get bigger as they bake!). Once your cookies are evenly portioned on baking sheets, stick them in your heated oven.

    Your cookies should only need less than 15 minutes to get slightly crispy and be perfectly baked. It’s best to keep an eye on your batch past the ten minute mark in the oven, looking for changes in texture and color. You want to aim for just a little bit of dark color around the edges of the bottom of each cookie, but not too much! Overdoing it in the oven will leave you with burnt, and sometimes ruined, cookies.

    Once the batch looks ready, carefully pull the baking sheets out of the oven, protecting your hands with mitts. The cookies will need an hour or so to cool and settle before they reach their perfect texture, but they can be eaten sooner if you like them extra soft and chewy!

    These delicious pumpkin cookies can be stored in the fridge or freezer and enjoyed for about five days. They’re the perfect treats to share with your loved ones, and you can easily whip up another batch if you run out! 

    Cleaning Up

    Cleanup after baking this recipe is, thank heaven, incredibly quick and simple. You’ll likely only have used a few bowls and utensils to prepare your dough, so a few quick rinses in the sink or dishwasher will leave you with a spotless kitchen once again. Your baking sheets can easily be cleaned by removing the parchment paper and gently scrubbing the surfaces of the sheets with a soapy sponge.

    This recipe is no-nonsense to the max, using minimal ingredients, utensils, and bowls. We wanted to make it as quick and simple of a recipe as possible, so that you can enjoy baking these delicious cookies even when you’re on a tight schedule! 

    Not A Baker? We Have You Covered!

    If you’re not a big fan of cooking and baking and you’d rather enjoy eating yummy treats rather than making them, have no fear – we’re here to help satisfy your cookie cravings! 

    All of our cookies are the perfect combination of soft, crispy, and sweet. Every batch is made with love, care, and the expert guidance of our faithful nun advisors. You don’t need to love baking to know delicious cookies when you taste them, so taste and see that Nunbelievable cookies are nun less than heavenly!

    For Fall or any other season, we’ve got the perfect wholesome, chewy cookies to enjoy – our signatureoatmeal raisin cookies! These cookies taste like sweet nostalgia, reminding you of everything that is warm, cozy, and comforting in life. Every bite of one of our incredible oatmeal raisin cookies is packed with crispy, flaky oats and juicy raisins. It’s the perfect combination to satisfy your sweet tooth and leave your belly feeling happy.

    If you’re not a fan of oatmeal raisin cookies, another delicious option that we have to offer is ourclassic chocolate chip cookies. These timeless treats are bound to give you your fix of chocolatey goodness, and they’re a perfect mix of chewy, melt-in-your-mouth chocolate chips and delicious dough. Heating one of our chocolate chip cookies up for a few seconds and enjoying it with a cup of tea or coffee on a cold fall day is sure to make you feel like you’ve gone to heaven.

    Delicious Cookies, Incredible Mission

    Any season is the perfect time to share some love, kindness, and generosity with the people who need it most. At Nunbelievable,every cookie we bake is made with a mission in mind. That mission is nun less than ending hunger! 

    We’re fighting to feed hungry men, women, and children who are suffering from hunger all over the United States, and every cookie you buy makes a difference. For each cookie purchased from Nunbelievable, we donate a meal to feed the hungry.

    There are over40 million men, women, andchildren suffering from hunger in the U.S. every day. The time is now to care for those in need, and one simple, practical way to get involved is by enjoying Nunbelievable cookies for dessert and sharing them with the people you love!

    Nunbelievable’s ultimate mission is to use the power of love, kindness, andgenerosityto build a world where hunger is a thing of the past. No one should have to suffer through the pain of not knowing where their next meal will come from. 

    This Fall, Winter, Spring, and Summer, join us in fighting to end hunger by enjoying some delicious cookies from Nunbelievable!